Cyberbullying law ruled unconstitutional by Nova Scotia Supreme Court
HALIFAX, Dec. 11, 2015, McInnes Cooper – The Supreme Court of Nova Scotia has declared the province's cyberbullying law to be unconstitutional. In a decision released on December 10, 2015, Justice Glen McDougall found that the Cyber-safety Act violates a Charter-guaranteed freedom of expression and "life, liberty and security of the person" rights, in a manner that cannot be upheld as a reasonable restriction that can be justified in a free and democratic society.
- See the original McInnes Cooper news release | Dec. 11, 2015
- See the response and statement from the Department of Justice at http://cyberscan.novascotia.ca/
The case, Crouch v Snell, 2015 NSSC 340, related to two former business partners who had a falling out. Mr. Crouch sought and obtained a cybersafety protection order before a justice of the peace in December 2014. The respondent, represented by McInnes Cooper's David Fraser, Ian Dunbar and Jane O'Neill, challenged the order and the legislation.
The Cyber-safety Act was passed unanimously by the Nova Scotia legislature in 2013, in the immediate aftermath of the tragic death of Rehtaeh Parsons. Among other things, the Act allows an alleged victim of cyberbullying to appear before a justice of the peace to obtain a cybersafety protection order. These orders can result in the confiscation of electronic devices and having individuals barred from using the internet. The alleged cyberbully never receives notice of this hearing and has no right to respond before the order is made. In this case, the justice of the peace ordered the respondent to delete all of his social media postings that didn't refer to anyone in particular since they may have referred to the complainant.
McInnes Cooper's David Fraser says the most problematic part of the Act is the definition of cyberbullying. "I often represent real victims of cyberbullying, but this definition is so broad it can be interpreted to include anything said or done online that could hurt someone's feelings," said Fraser.
In the meantime, Fraser says that cyberbullying legislation is still needed, but that the government should go back to the drawing board to provide the right tools to help real victims.
"The court was clear that victims of cyberbullying will continue to have access to civil and criminal law remedies while the government has an opportunity to create a law that complies with the Charter," said Fraser. "The tragedies of Rehtaeh Parsons and Amanda Todd have shown us, tragically in hindsight, that the police need to take cyberbullying seriously and to use the tools already available to them."
Statement from the Nova Scotia Department of Justice:
On December 11, 2015, the Cyber-Safety Act was struck down after the Supreme Court of Nova Scotia ruled that the legislation violated the Charter of Rights and Freedoms.
The Department of Justice is disappointed and believes in the premise of this legislation. Cyberbullying can have detrimental impacts and we remain committed to protecting victims of cyberbullying. We are taking time to review this decision and consider all of our options.
The CyberSCAN investigative unit will continue to operate but will shift focus to education and public awareness. Victims of online bullying can still call us for advice and help redirect their cases to the appropriate authority or agency for help.
Effective immediately, however, any complaint involving criminal behavior like harassment or threats will be directed to the police. Police will not deal with cyberbullying unless it has a criminal element.
We are proud to be cyber-safety leaders in Canada. We will continue to ensure Nova Scotians have a level of protection against cyberbullying.